Many happy returns, but there are catches

By Jody Rohlena on December 25, 2012 12:01:00 am

Thinkstock78618231_SSBLOG_SHOPPING_returnsHow was your holiday haul this year? If you’re like a lot of people you opened at least one gift you aren’t too jazzed about. In one poll, one in five adults admits to receiving a holiday gift they didn’t want—but that number sounds low, doesn’t it? Last year was a record for returns: $46.3 billion worth of gifts went back! And in case you were wondering, in-laws were named the worst gift givers.

So what do you do with unwanted gifts? If you’re lucky, you got a gift receipt, so returns shouldn’t be a hassle. If you aren’t so lucky, read retailers’ returns policies on their websites before you schlep to the store. Here are 7 returns gotchas to avoid, from our January issue:

Not all stores take back online purchases. Sports Authority stores won’t take back anything bought on its website. Other stores—Macy’s, Ann Taylor, Loft, Gap, Old Navy, and Banana Republic are a few examples—won’t take back certain items.

Some gift cards aren’t returnable. Apple, Kenneth Cole, Nordstrom, and other stores won’t take gift cards back. A better bet: sell them on reseller sites like Plastic Jungle.com and Cardpool.com.

Using PayPal can limit returns. One exception is Target; you can get cash back for PayPal purchases in stores (but only store credit online).

Free gifts can cost you. If you get a freebie promo gift with purchase and you decide to return that purchase, not returning the freebie can cost you.

No gift receipt could mean no return. Williams-Sonoma, Bloomingdale’s, and others have strict no-receipt returns policies. You could be out of luck.

You may be stuck with outlet items. The bargains may be great, but returns not so much. The Land of Nod, Crate & Barrel, and others won’t take back outlet purchases.

Restocking fees can bite you. Electronics and media items like DVDs are notorious for restocking fees, meaning you won’t get back the item’s full value even if you return it promptly and unopened, receipt or no receipt.

I hope you’re happily keeping all your holiday gifts! But good luck with those returns next time.

Subscribe to ShopSmart today!
Jody Rohlena

Jody Rohlena

Posted at 12:01:00 AM in
Consumer protection | Customer service | Featured | Gifts | Holidays | Jody Rohlena | Money & Shopping | Online Shopping | Shopping

Print This Page

Carol Anderson

04:58:59 AM on Wed Dec 26 2012

In your January 2013 issue you state that Kohl's "lets you return anything, anytime, even without a receipt." for Christmas 2011, my daughter-in-law gave (d-i-l) me a digital picture frame from Kohl's. I already had one so I asked her for the receipt so I could return it. I learned, when I was at the return desk, that my d-i-l had given me a rebate receipt. The associate told me that even though the receipt clearly stated that my d-i-l had paid $55 for the frame, she could only give me $29 because it was a rebate receipt. I couldn't see giving Kohl's a gift of $16 so I gave the frame to my friend instead. I'm not impressed with Kohl's return policy.

Post a Comment

All comments are reviewed by our moderators, and will not appear on this blog unless they have been approved. Comments that do not relate directly to the blog entry's contents, are commercial in nature, contain objectionable or inappropriate material, or otherwise violate our User Agreement or Privacy Policy, will not be approved. Approved posts generally appear within 24 hours of receipt. For general inquiries not related to this blog, please contact Customer Service.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In